2026 Broadway Bound Theatre Festival in
New York City Winner
Aug 5 - 9
"Once In a Lifetime, Again" has been selected as one of twelve winners in the 2026 Broadway Bound Theatre Festival in New York City, which will take place from July 20 to August 16 at the AMT Theater, 354 West 45th Street in Manhattan.
For tickets, news, and information about our performances at the Broadway Bound Theatre Festival click here.
Once in a Lifetime, Again
an original musical
When Jesse Davidson’s wife of 30 years dies, he is crushed by grief and remorse. He must find a new path as he embarks on the tender, funny roller coaster of searching for love again.
The Story
It was love at first sight when Jesse and Lydia met at a college party in 1974. Soon enough, they were one of many couples in the generation thrown into new gender roles: two careers, shared parenting —and with that, new stresses, conflict, and pressures.
When Lydia dies of cancer in her late fifties, Jesse is devastated by grief and remorse that he had allowed his all-consuming career to take priority over his love for Lydia. After lashing out at work, he is told he must begin therapy.
We meet Jesse as he begins seeing Dr. Carrie Little, a therapist who has little patience for his skepticism and unwillingness to engage. Through their work, Jesse discovers that he can examine his failings and regrets with unsparing honesty by writing original songs. Finally ready to try again, 65 years old and a bit lost in a dating world with new rules, Jesse sets out on an occasionally awkward, often comic, and always tender search to find love anew.
Listen to songs from
‘Once in a Lifetime, Again’
The score includes fifteen original songs, with lyrics and music by Stephen H. Gardner. Click on the tab for links to all the songs.
Creative Development
-
"Once In a Lifetime, Again" was selected as one of twelve winners in the 2026 Broadway Bound Theatre Festival in New York City, which will take place from July 20 to August 16 at the AMT Theater, 354 West 45th Street in Manhattan. Learn more
-
Once In a Lifetime, Again was selected by The York Theatre Company for its prestigious Reading Development Series. Two Actors’ Equity Readings were performed on September 9, 2024.
David Lutken* - Jesse Davidson
David Lutken is a Broadway actor, singer, and musician who created and starred in WOODY SEZ, THE LIFE AND MUSIC OF WOODY GUTHRIE.
Broadway: INHERIT THE WIND, RING OF FIRE, THE CIVIL WAR, THE WILL ROGERS FOLLIES.Michele Ragusa* - Jill, Susannah, Elodie, Darcy, Maddie, Tracey, Nina
Broadway: FLYING OVER SUNSET, YOUNG FRANKENSTEIN, URINETOWN THE MUSICAL.
Off-Broadway: THE BUTCHER BOY, Irish RepAndrea Frierson* - Carrie LittleBroadway: THE LION KING, ONCE ON THIS ISLAND, BRING IN ‘DA NOISE/BRING IN DA’ FUNK, MARIE CHRISTINE, FOR COLORED GIRLS
Leenya Rideout* - Bass, and Frances (“Mutiny”) Kaine
Broadway: WAR HORSE, CYRANO DE BERGERAC, COMPANY, CABARET
Off Broadway: MUSIC CITY, WILD ABANDON, AS YOU LIKE IT, TAMING OF THE SHREW, BEFORE WE'RE GONE, FIRE & AIRThe 4-piece band included Kevin Kuhn, lead guitarist for ALADDIN and THE LION KING on Broadway. The AEA reading for producers and theater professionals was directed by Samantha (“Sami”) Saltzman, with Music Direction by Logan Medland.
—
*Member Actors’ Equity Association -
An Actors’ Equity Staged Reading of 'Once in a Lifetime, Again' was held at New York City's Pearl Studios In September, 2022. The cast featured:
John Dossett* - Jesse Davidson
Broadway: Recently starred as the Wizard in WICKED, PARADISE SQUARE, WAR PAINT, CHICAGO.
Off-Broadway: DEAR EVAN HANSEN. Film: THE ORANGES, LITTLE MANHATTAN.Michele Ragusa* - Carrie Little and supporting female characters
Broadway: FLYING OVER SUNSET, YOUNG FRANKENSTEIN, URINETOWN THE MUSICAL.
Off-Broadway: THE BUTCHER BOY, Irish Rep.Jason Smith - Akila, Bass player NYC: SKINFOLK, dir: Mei Ann Teo, BEULAHLAND.
The 4-piece band included Kevin Kuhn, lead guitarist for ALADDIN and THE LION KING on Broadway. The AEA reading for producers and theater professionals was directed by Jay Stern, with Music Direction by Logan Medland, and produced by Laura Lundy, Blue Panther Productions.
—
*Member Actors’ Equity Association -
Under the direction of Logan Medland, Broadway musical performer Donnie Kehr recorded seven of the original songs in ‘Once in a Lifetime, Again’ at Millrose Studios, New York City.
-
Music Director Logan Medland, Writer/Composer-Lyricist Stephen H. Gardner, and Creative Producer Laura Lundy convened for a 5-day script development workshop and private reading at Open Jar Studios, New York City. Jen Wineman directed AEA actors Tait Ruppert and Michele Ragusa.
A note about the show, from the writer.
Thanks for coming to our website to learn more about ‘Once In a Lifetime, Again’.
Writing the book, lyrics, and music to ‘Once In a Lifetime, Again’ – and the exhilarating experience of working with actors, directors, and musicians to bring it to life in readings – has been, well, a once in a lifetime experience. I have been delighted by the reception it has received from theater professionals and audiences alike… and pleased to hear that it has caused more than a few conversations in households with what I will call "vintage demographics." As Jesse Davidson asks at the outset of the show, “Hey Boomers – it’s 10:00. Do you know where your relationship is?”
I’ve long been puzzled why more has not been written about the sudden changes to gender roles experienced by the young men and women graduating college in the 1970s and early 1980s. Most grew up with one archetype for family life: Dad goes to the office, and Mom stays home with the kids. Then, in a flash, it all changed. Young women graduating from college in 1975 not only had the opportunity to seek careers, it was almost expected in a world turned on its head by the feminist movement of the ‘60s.
At first, two career households were easy enough. But it got crazy when babies arrived. Suddenly young women were expected to be lawyers/doctors/bankers – and full-time moms. Many young men were torn by the conflict between their traditional societal programming as “providers,” and the sudden new imperative to share the responsibilities of parenting. Many could not navigate their inner turmoil, frustrated that co-parenting meant leaving the office at 6:00 while peers stayed, working longer hours, and winning the big promotion.
In young marriages, it all created tension, unrealistic expectations, conflict, and hurt. Some young women gave up, surrendering their careers and reverting to the old paradigm. Some marriages suffered, withered, and ultimately ended. And there were the couples who kept trying, determined that they could have it all, do it all. Perhaps those felt the most stress of all.
Welcome to the world of Jesse and Lydia Davidson, a love-at-first-sight couple whose fairy tale marriage was strained to breaking by the pressures of dual (and dueling!) careers, unequal co-parenting, disillusionment, emotional distance, and then terrifying illness.
Visit, then, the world of widower Jesse, who must learn how to deal with his rage, grief, remorse, and regret… and then set out to find a new romance in a very different world, and a very different age.
Some of the most interesting comments about the play came from the people who noted that theaters are filled with audiences that are older than 50 — but very, very few plays are about the arc of the lives of those people who are in the theater that night. Sure, some plays might take nostalgic looks at their younger years. There are dark plays about aging couples staring at impending death. And there are unserious romps like the movie “Cocoon,” that seem like a 25-year old’s view of an old-age home filled with stale, sullen, decrepit old people.
I have not seen enough theater that tries to portray what contemporary life looks like when parenting is done, retirement arrives, and life partners die. When still-vital people take stock of their lives, look for new challenges, and —for the many people who find themselves suddenly single, again— yearn to find once in a lifetime, again.
A friend who saw one of the readings of my show remarked that it was a “classic coming-of-age play.”
Then she laughed and added, “that is, if the age you are coming to is sixty-five.”
--Stephen H. Gardner
November 14, 2024
Here are some quotes
from attendees at the readings
To receive the script, to view an archival recording of The York Theatre Reading Development Series September 2024 evening performance, or to receive information about presenting ONCE IN A LIFETIME, AGAIN,
contact steve@onceinalifetimeagain.com